Rotherie Durell Foster, 37, Camarillo, Ca
Rotherie Durell Foster, 37, Camarillo, Ca

VENTURA, Calif. – After a seven-day preliminary hearing, a Ventura County Superior Court Judge has ordered Rotherie Durell
Foster (DOB 11/03/85), of Camarillo, to stand trial on 35 felony counts, including the murders of Jose Velasquez and Bill
Levy, a violent armed robbery in Fillmore, and a series of financial fraud crimes. The court also held Foster to answer on
six special circumstances and all special allegations alleged by prosecutors, including murder for financial gain, personal
and intentional discharge of a firearm, and murder by poison.

Foster is accused of murdering Mr. Velasquez in 2022, stealing his van and financial information, and later disposed of his
body in the Santa Monica Mountains. That same year, Foster is charged with murdering Mr. Levy through intentional fentanyl
poisoning. While he committed Mr. Levy’s murder, Foster stole Mr. Levy’s phone, bank card, and credit cards in order to
drain his bank accounts.

Foster is also accused of committing an armed robbery at La Unica Mini Mart in Fillmore in July 2022, where employees were
held at gunpoint, bound with duct tape, and robbed of thousands of dollars in cash. In addition, he faces multiple charges
of financial fraud targeting vulnerable and elderly victims.

Senior Deputy District Attorney Amber Lee, a member of the Ventura County District Attorney’s Office Major Crimes Homicide
Unit, is prosecuting the case.

Foster is scheduled to be arraigned on the information on October 2, 2025, at 9:00 a.m. in courtroom 12 of the Ventura
County Superior Court. He remains in custody with no bail.

Case: 2023001092

Defendant Information:

Rotherie Durell Foster (DOB 11/03/85) Camarillo

Charges:

• PC 187(a) – Murder (2 counts)

• PC 211 – Robbery (4 counts)

• PC 459 – Burglary

• PC 487(a) – Grand theft (3 counts)

•PC 368(d) – Theft, forgery and identity theft from an elder/dependent adult (10 counts)

• PC 470 – Forgery (2 counts)

• PC 530.5(a) – Identity theft (9 counts)

• PC 25850(a) – Carry a loaded firearm in a vehicle

• PC 30305(a)(1) – Possession of ammunition by a prohibited person

• PC 29800 – Felon in possession of a firearm (2 counts)

Special allegations:

• PC 189(a) – 1st degree murder

• PC 190.2(a)(1) – Murder for financial gain

• PC 190.2(a)(17)(A) – Murder during the commission of robbery

• PC 190.2(a)(17)(G) – Murder during the commission of burglary

• PC 190.2(a)(3) – Multiple murders

• PC 190.2(a)(19) – Murder of a witness

• PC 667(c) – Serious or violent felony (strike prior)

• PC 667(e)(2)(C)(iii) – Prior serious or violent felony conviction

• PC 12022.53(d) – Personal and intentional discharge of a firearm causing death or great bodily injury

• PC 12022.53(b) – Personal use of a firearm

• PC 667(a)(1) – Prior serious felony conviction

• PC 667.9(a) – Crime committed against a vulnerable victim

• PC 790(b) – Jurisdiction

***

Contact: Joey Buttitta

Title: Communications Manager/PIO

Phone: (805) 767-3400

Email: Joey.Buttitta@venturacounty.gov

Approved: PN

Date: September 5, 2025

Release No.: 25-111

***

ORIGINAL REPORT:

Gazette posted – online Wednesday, March 1st, 2023

On 02/08/2023, detectives with the Sheriff’s Major Crimes Bureau arrested (S1) Rotherie Foster for the robbery at La Unica
Mini Market.

On 07/03/2022, at approximately 07:42 AM, deputies from the Fillmore Police Department responded to a robbery that occurred
at La Unica Mini Market, located along the 500-block of Old Telegraph Road in the City of Fillmore. Deputies learned that
two unknown male suspects entered the market and brandished their firearms at the store’s employees while demanding money.
The suspects took an undisclosed amount of money and fled the store. Detectives from the Ventura County Sheriff’s Major
Crimes Bureau responded to assist with the investigation.

During the investigation, detectives identified one of the robbery suspects as (A)-Rotherie Foster. On 02/08/2023,
detectives contacted Foster at the Todd Road Jail, where he was incarcerated for an unrelated case. Foster was arrested and
supple mentally booked for PC 211-Robbery.

On 02/08/2023, the Ventura County District Attorney’s Office filed one count of second-degree robbery against Foster. Foster
remains in custody and his next court date is scheduled for 04/12/2023.

This is an on-going investigation. The Ventura County Sheriff’s Major Crimes Bureau is seeking the public’s assistance in

identifying the second suspect. If anyone has information that would be helpful in this case, please contact Detective Corey
Stump at (805) 384-4745 or by email at Corey.Stump@Ventura.Org.

***

Nature of Incident: Robbery Arrest / Request for Public Assistance

Report Number: 22-87452

Location: 500-block of Old Telegraph Road
Date & Time: 07/03/2022 at 07:42 AM

Unit(s) Responsible: Fillmore Patrol, Fillmore Police Department Investigation Unit, Sheriff’s Major Crimes Bureau

(S)uspects, (V)ictims, (P)arty, (D)ecedent City of Residence Age

(S1) Rotherie Foster, 37, Camarillo

(S2) Unknown

Prepared by: Sergeant Francisco Jauregui

Approved by: Captain Victor Medina

 


 
At Tuesday night’s city council meeting the city presented a proclamation for September 2025 as Suicide Prevention Awareness Month and encouraged community-wide participation in suicide prevent efforts. Pictured is Mayor Christina Villaseñor presenting Maya Zumaya with the proclamation.
At Tuesday night’s city council meeting the city presented a proclamation for September 2025 as Suicide Prevention Awareness Month and encouraged community-wide participation in suicide prevent efforts. Pictured is Mayor Christina Villaseñor presenting Maya Zumaya with the proclamation.

CITY OF FILLMORE CITY COUNCIL AND SUCCESSOR AGENCY REGULAR MEETING TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2025, 6:30 PM CITY HALL

All items passed 5-0 vote.

AGENDA

1. CALL TO ORDER

2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

3. ROLL CALL

4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA

5. PRESENTATIONS

5.A PROCLAIMING SEPTEMBER 2025 AS SUICIDE PREVENTION AWARENESS MONTH AND ENCOURAGING COMMUNITY-WIDE PARTICIPATION IN SUICIDE PREVENTION EFFORTS

6. PUBLIC COMMENTS

7. CITY COUNCIL REPORTS, RECOMMENDATIONS, COMMENTS, COMMITTEE, COMMISSION, AND BOARD REPORTS

8. CONSENT CALENDAR
RECOMMENDATION FOR ITEM 8A. THROUGH 8B. IS TO BE APPROVED BY VOICE VOTE.

8.A CITY OF FILLMORE WARRANT REGISTER-SEPTEMBER 9, 2025 CITY OF FILLMORE WARRANT REGISTER-SEPTEMBER 9, 2025.PDF

8.B AUGUST 26, 2025 - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES AUGUST 26, 2025 REGULAR CITY COUCNIL MEETING MINUTES.PDF

9. NEW BUSINESS

9.A AMENDED AND RESTATED AGREEMENT FOR SOLID WASTE HANDLING SERVICES BETWEEN CITY OF FILLMORE AND SANTA CLARA VALLEY DISPOSAL AND CONDUCT A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE PROPOSED SOLID WASTE COLLECTION RATES AS REQUIRED FOR A PROPOSITION 218 MAJORITY PROTEST PROCESS AND
APPROVE RESOLUTION NO. 25-4083 TO AUTHORIZE RATES AND ANNUAL INCREASES FOR A FOUR-YEAR (4-YEAR) PERIOD COMMENCING OCTOBER 1, 2025 THROUGH JUNE 30, 2029 WITHIN THE CITY OF FILLMORE
SR RESTATED HARRISON AGREEMENT - RATE INCREASE 2025.PDF

9.B PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDER ZONING ORDINANCE TEXT AMENDMENT 25-02 (ZOA 25-02) TO IMPLEMENT 2021-2029 HOUSING ELEMENT
SR ORD 25-987 HOUSING ELEMENT UPDATE.PDF

9.C AUTHORIZATION TO PURCHASE KM INTERNATIONAL 2-TON HOT BOX THROUGH THE SOURCEWELL COOPERATIVE PURCHASING PROGRAM
SR - AUTHORIZATION TO PURCHASE KM INTERNATIONAL 2-TON HOT BOX. FINAL.PDF

10. CITY MANAGER
CITY MANAGER VERBAL REPORT

11. CLOSED SESSION

11.A CLOSED SESSION - SEPTEMBER 9, 2025 SEPTEMBER 09, 2025 - CLOSED SESSION.PDF

12. ADJOURNMENT

MAYOR CHRISTINA VILLASEÑOR ADJOURNS TO THE NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING AT 6:30 P.M. ON TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2025, CITY HALL, 250 CENTRAL AVENUE, FILLMORE, CA 93015.

 


 
Denise Berrington, New FUSD Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Denise Berrington, New FUSD Assistant Superintendent of Business Services

Denise Berrington is a seasoned school business leader with more than 17 years of experience in California public education. She specializes in fiscal stewardship, facilities management, transportation, energy efficiency, and long-range planning, and has a strong record of leading organizational improvements that enhance efficiency, reduce costs, and support student success.

Most recently, Denise served as Director of Maintenance, Operations, and Transportation for Moorpark Unified School District, where she led a team of 75 employees, oversaw multimillion-dollar construction projects, and managed district-wide safety initiatives. She secured more than $7.5 million in grants to modernize HVAC systems and $6 million to launch one of the county’s largest clean-energy school bus programs, driving major sustainability and efficiency gains.

Prior to that, she spent nearly 12 years with the Fillmore Unified School District in various leadership roles, where she built a strong foundation in facilities and organizational management. Throughout her career, she has been recognized for her collaborative leadership style, ability to build strong teams, and strategic approach to aligning operations with district-wide goals.

Denise holds a bachelor’s degree from Southern Utah University and is completing her MBA with a concentration in Finance. She completed a certificate from the USC School Business Management Program, earned her School Business Finance Certificate through CASBO, and is a CASBO Certified Chief Business Official (CBO).

 


 
Civic Pride Volunteers named the Aguilar Family as the September 2025 Yard of the Month winners. Pictured is the family in from of their beautiful yard (l-r); Victor, Candy, Nick, Veronica, Alexis & Michael Aguilar. Inset, a deep purple shrub with beautifully shaped leaves, described by Veronica as a red blooming Hibiscus they brought from Mexico as seeds & have successfully grown. Photo credit Linda Nunes.
Civic Pride Volunteers named the Aguilar Family as the September 2025 Yard of the Month winners. Pictured is the family in from of their beautiful yard (l-r); Victor, Candy, Nick, Veronica, Alexis & Michael Aguilar. Inset, a deep purple shrub with beautifully shaped leaves, described by Veronica as a red blooming Hibiscus they brought from Mexico as seeds & have successfully grown. Photo credit Linda Nunes.
Enlarge Photo

By Linda Nunes

Civic Pride Volunteers have selected the yard at 731 Balden, belonging to Victor & Veronica Aguilar and their family which includes Candy, Brandon, Alexis, Michael & Nick, for the September “Yard of the Month.” The family moved to Fillmore from Santa Paula in 2021.

Victor is the one who enjoys the yard work & designed the miniature tree Roses to surround the inside of the white picket fence. These Roses have blooms of red, shades of pink & orange. He removed a big tree in the center of the yard & planted a tree that has four different fruits grafted on; apricot, plum & two different types of peaches. All of these have produced fruit, says Victor.

Other fruit trees in the front yard are Pomegranate, Strawberry Guava, & Lime. Veronica says they have trees with oranges & figs in the backyard. Victor trained a large seedless green grape vine to grow across the entry way & on across the top of the garage door opening, giving the home great “curb appeal”.

Near the entry way, a very unusual, deep purple shrub with beautifully shaped leaves was described by Veronica as a red blooming Hibiscus that they brought from Mexico as seeds & have successfully grown it into a show piece. Other plants seen are white grandiflora roses, small palm trees, an Aloe & tomatoes with lettuce in a pot.

The Aguilar family looks forward to exploring Otto & Sons Nursery to use their gift card award. Civic Pride Volunteers appreciate Otto & Sons Nursery for generously providing this award to keep our project going. We have seen creative improvements all around the community…making Fillmore beautiful!

 

On Wednesday, August 27, 2025, investigators with the Ventura County District Attorney’s Office arrested Kevin John Reynolds (DOB 09/27/84), of Newbury Park, after executing a search warrant at his home. The search warrant was part of an ongoing investigation by the Ventura County District Attorney’s Office Bureau of Investigation Child Exploitation Unit, in coordination with the FBI and the Ventura County Sheriff’s Office.

Reynolds was identified during an undercover operation targeting people involved in downloading and distributing CSAM. During a search of his residence, investigators seized multiple computers and external hard drives.

Reynolds was arrested at the scene for possession of CSAM and distribution of CSAM and booked into the Ventura County Main Jail.

“The sexual exploitation of our children is one of the most disturbing crimes our investigators confront,” said Chief Investigator Scott Whitney. “Our investigators work tirelessly to identify and arrest those who seek to harm the most vulnerable members of our community.”

Investigators learned that Reynolds is employed as a chemistry teacher at Fillmore High School. The Fillmore Unified School District and the Fillmore Police Department were immediately notified.
The court set Reynolds’ bail at $50,000, which he posted. He was given a court date of September 10, 2025.

***
Contact: Joey Buttitta
Title: Communications Manager/PIO
Phone: (805) 767-3400
Email: Joey.Buttitta@venturacounty.gov
Approved: SW
Date: August 29, 2025
Release No.: 25-109

UPDATE:
On Thursday, August 28, 2025, at approximately 4pm, Reynolds arrived at the high school attempting to pick up some personal property. School staff contacted the School Resource Officer (SRO), who arrived and contacted Reynolds. Based on the circumstances, Reynolds was arrested for violation of Penal Code section 626.8 (a)(2)- Trespassing on School Grounds. Reynolds was booked at the Pre-Trial Detention Facility and released early Friday morning after posting bail.

 
A DUI Checkpoint held on Friday night at Central Avenue & Santa Clara, Fillmore resulted in the arrest of two drivers for DUI offenses. Eight drivers were cited for operating a vehicle unlicensed or with a suspended/revoked license. Photo credit Sebastian Ramirez.
A DUI Checkpoint held on Friday night at Central Avenue & Santa Clara, Fillmore resulted in the arrest of two drivers for DUI offenses. Eight drivers were cited for operating a vehicle unlicensed or with a suspended/revoked license. Photo credit Sebastian Ramirez.
Enlarge Photo

Fillmore, California. – On August 29th, 2025, a DUI checkpoint was held on Central Avenue near Santa Clara Street from 7:00 p.m. to 1:00 a.m. A total of 233 drivers were contacted at the checkpoint.

Eight drivers were cited for operating a vehicle unlicensed or with a suspended/revoked license. Two drivers were arrested for DUI offenses.

DUI checkpoint locations are determined based on reported incidents of impaired driving-related crashes. The primary purpose of DUI checkpoints is to promote public safety by taking suspected impaired drivers off roads.

Funding for this program was provided by a grant from the California Office of Traffic Safety, through the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

Prepared by: Sergeant Corey Stump
News Release Date: September 2, 2025
Approved by: Captain Eduardo Malagon

 
Christine Schieferle, Fillmore Unified Superintendent
Christine Schieferle, Fillmore Unified Superintendent

August 28, 2025.
Dear FHS Community,

The Ventura County District Attorney’s Office has informed the Fillmore Unified School District (“District”) that on August 27, 2025, at approximately 8:45 a.m., Kevin Reynolds, a Chemistry Teacher at Fillmore High School (“FHS”), was arrested on charges of unlawful possession or control of inappropriate images as defined by Penal Code sections 311.11 and 311.1.

At this time, we do not have information that any current or former students are involved in these allegations. However, the seriousness of these charges are not taken lightly. As the legal process moves forward, we want to make it clear that Mr. Reynolds will not be returning to any District campus.
Please know that the District is working closely with the relevant authorities and will continue to cooperate fully with their investigations.

Our top priority remains ensuring a safe, secure, and supportive learning environment for all of our students. The District is actively working to secure an alternate teacher to continue delivering high-quality instruction for the remainder of the school year.

We sincerely appreciate your understanding and support as we navigate this matter. Should you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to reach out to Mr. Roger Adams, Assistant Superintendent for Human Resources and Student Services at 805-524-8029.

Thank you for your continued partnership in supporting the well-being and success of our students.
Sincerely,
Christine Schieferle, Superintendent

 
On Tuesday, August 26, 2025, the City of Fillmore recognized the Fillmore Little League Championship 14U District 83 Team, pictured above. The city presented certificates of recognition to the Fillmore Little League after their championship win, defeating the opposing team, 18-7. In 2023, the Little League also won the championship, bringing home the title to Fillmore for the first time in 40 years. Certificates were also provided to the coaching staff and the team mom who contributed to the teams’ success.
On Tuesday, August 26, 2025, the City of Fillmore recognized the Fillmore Little League Championship 14U District 83 Team, pictured above. The city presented certificates of recognition to the Fillmore Little League after their championship win, defeating the opposing team, 18-7. In 2023, the Little League also won the championship, bringing home the title to Fillmore for the first time in 40 years. Certificates were also provided to the coaching staff and the team mom who contributed to the teams’ success.
Enlarge Photo
 
On Monday, September 1st, at 4:14 p.m., Fillmore Fire Department and Ventura County Fire responded to a 100x100 spot fire in the Santa Clara riverbed that was spreading slowly. A copter was requested but cancelled due to a forward progress stop. About two hours later, the Fillmore City Fire Department responded to the same place as before to cool down the hotspots. Cause of the fire is under investigation. Photo credit Sebastian Ramirez.
On Monday, September 1st, at 4:14 p.m., Fillmore Fire Department and Ventura County Fire responded to a 100x100 spot fire in the Santa Clara riverbed that was spreading slowly. A copter was requested but cancelled due to a forward progress stop. About two hours later, the Fillmore City Fire Department responded to the same place as before to cool down the hotspots. Cause of the fire is under investigation. Photo credit Sebastian Ramirez.
Enlarge Photo
 
Above is the current construction site for the new Fillmore High Athletic Complex which is in full effect. The construction site is scheduled to be completed in December 2026. The brand-new 43,000 square-foot athletic complex that will serve Fillmore’s high school students. Online at www.FillmoreGazette.com are original photos attached along with other construction photos and construction information. Inset, a rendering of what the final project will look like.
Above is the current construction site for the new Fillmore High Athletic Complex which is in full effect. The construction site is scheduled to be completed in December 2026. The brand-new 43,000 square-foot athletic complex that will serve Fillmore’s high school students. Online at www.FillmoreGazette.com are original photos attached along with other construction photos and construction information. Inset, a rendering of what the final project will look like.
Enlarge Photo
Construction has officially begun on the brand-new 43,000 square-foot athletic complex that will serve Fillmore’s high school students. Thanks to the support of the communities of Fillmore and Piru in passing Measure G, this vision is becoming a reality. With a projected completion date of December 2026, the complex will provide modern athletic spaces to support our student-athletes for years to come.

Construction crews have already made significant progress at the site. The old baseball field turf has been pulverized in place and mixed into ground. Site grading is actively underway, with heavy machinery preparing the land for development. The transformation is evident when comparing the current cleared and leveled site to the architectural renderings of what’s to come—a state-of-the-art athletic complex complete with updated facilities, expanded parking, and landscaped areas to welcome students, families, and the community.

Fillmore Unified School District Superintendent Christine Schieferle, said, “As we move forward, we want to extend a heartfelt thank you to our community members for their support, trust, and vision. This project is a direct result of your investment in our schools and our students’ futures. Together, we are building something extraordinary for generations of students to come. Go Flashes!
Construction has officially begun on the brand-new 43,000 square-foot athletic complex that will serve Fillmore’s high school students. Thanks to the support of the communities of Fillmore and Piru in passing Measure G, this vision is becoming a reality. With a projected completion date of December 2026, the complex will provide modern athletic spaces to support our student-athletes for years to come. Construction crews have already made significant progress at the site. The old baseball field turf has been pulverized in place and mixed into ground. Site grading is actively underway, with heavy machinery preparing the land for development. The transformation is evident when comparing the current cleared and leveled site to the architectural renderings of what’s to come—a state-of-the-art athletic complex complete with updated facilities, expanded parking, and landscaped areas to welcome students, families, and the community. Fillmore Unified School District Superintendent Christine Schieferle, said, “As we move forward, we want to extend a heartfelt thank you to our community members for their support, trust, and vision. This project is a direct result of your investment in our schools and our students’ futures. Together, we are building something extraordinary for generations of students to come. Go Flashes!
Enlarge Photo